WishingUWell Insights

We’re not only consultants—we’re here to help you with all-things Amazon.
Read our blog to get your questions answered.

Important Metrics to Win the Buy Box [Or Featured Offer]

The Amazon Buy Box is the most coveted spot on any product listing. A seller can win the Buy Box by offering buyers a lower price, faster shipping, and better customer service than their competitors. This blog post will cover how you can increase your chances of winning the Buy Box. Topics include:
  1. What is the Amazon Buy Box?
  2. Why It’s Important for the Customer
  3. Why It’s Important for the Seller
  4. Buy Box Eligibility Requirements
  5. How to Check Eligibility
  6. How to Win the Buy Box
  7. Additional Tips for Scoring the Featured Offer
  8. How to Confirm You’ve Won the Featured Offer

What is the Amazon Buy Box?

The Buy Box, also referred to as the Featured Offer, is the white box prominently displayed on the right-hand side of any product detail page. The box allows customers to effortlessly buy new products by clicking the “Add to Cart” and “Buy Now” button. By doing this, they have selected the Buy Box offer—which generates over 80% of sales on Amazon.

A key aspect of Amazon’s marketplace is that multiple sellers can sell the same product at the same time. This provides customers the best buying experience possible because sellers can compete for this coveted spot to gain a greater share of the sales—that usually means having the lowest price, fastest shipping, and best customer service.

Get help with competitive pricing, Prime eligibility, and customer service today!

Contact WishingUWell—we’re here to help you with all-things Amazon.

Why It’s Important for the Customer

The white box highlights sellers with top performance metrics and the lowest prices. While also providing customers the option to see offers from other sellers. This customer-centric feature provides the best buying options because consumers can compare prices, delivery dates, and seller ratings. See how it works here

Why It’s Important for the Seller

Amazon doesn’t award the Featured Offer to the same seller everytime; instead, they use an algorithm and key performance metrics to decide each seller’s “share” or percentage of the Buy Box. This rotational model switches the Buy Box from one seller to another giving everyone different percentages of the primary offer. There are two steps Amazon takes to select offers to feature:

  1. Amazon determines which items are eligible to be featured based on criteria that are designed to give customers a great shopping experience.
  2. Amazon selects compelling offers to feature from among this pool of eligible offers.

Buy Box Eligibility Requirements

To be eligible for the Featured Offer, you must meet the following criteria:

  1. Must have a Professional Seller Account to be considered eligible—Individual Seller Accounts cannot compete.
  2. Must have a successful sales history—experience & consistency matters!
  3. Must sell items in new condition. Used items cannot be featured.
  4. Must have available inventory. Otherwise, the Buy Box will rotate to another seller.

Need help setting up your Professional Seller Account?

Contact WishingUWell—we know Amazon.

How to Check Eligibility

Amazon is always trying to protect its customers—in this instance, they remove Buy Box eligibility from sellers based on account performance and other risk factors. To find out if your products are eligible, follow these steps:

  1. Go to Manage Inventory page in Seller Central
  2. Click Preferences
  3. Select Buy Box Eligible and save changes
  4. Buy Box Eligible column will appear next to each of your ASINs
  5. Check status there

Or, follow this link to input your ASIN or SKU.

How to Win the Buy Box

After Amazon determines your eligibility, they start to compare a variety of metrics and variables amongst sellers to determine the winner. While no one knows the exact formula for winning the Buy Box, here are a few metrics that will influence your chances of winning:

  1. Fulfillment Method: Amazon will look to your fulfillment method to help determine the Featured Offer. While FBA & Seller Fulfilled Prime used to be the preferred method, Fulfilled By Merchant still has a chance—though it still seems unlikely to beat FBA.
  2. Price: Not just the price of your product, but the total charge associated with getting a shipment to its destination. Keep a low landed price!
  3. Stock Availability: Products with immediate fulfillment are always favored for the Buy Box. Also, the Buy Box creates an increase for demand and Amazon wants to ensure you can meet that demand.
  4. Order Defect Rate (ODR): For a serious chance of winning the Featured Offer, keep these metrics below 1%—Negative Feedback Rating and A-to-Z Guarantee Claim Rate.
  5. Feedback Rating/Count: Amazon looks at seller feedback from the last 30 days, 90 days, 12 months, and lifetime to weigh between sellers. The amount of feedback, the most recent feedback, and your seller history are important factors to consider to provide Amazon customers the best experience.
  6. Customer Response Rate: Customer service is essential to winning the primary offer because the entire Amazon experience is centered around the customer. Make sure you are replying within 12 hours of someone contacting you.
  7. Refund Rate: It goes without saying that a lower refund rate helps you earn the Buy Box offer. It demonstrates that your product accurately matches the listing, is of high-quality, and is packaged properly upon leaving your facility.

Additional Tips for Scoring the Featured Offer

  1. Amazon Brand Registry: Maintain control and protect your brand on Amazon by enrolling in Brand Registry. This ensures your branded-content remains the same across all of your listings and gives you the authority to verify and change content based on the facts of your products. It also prevents returns and negative feedback from customers by providing the most up-to-date information.
  2. Competitive Pricing: With an increase in sellers, brands, and products on Amazon, pricing is extremely competitive. It’s also one of the ultimate factors that customers consider when making a purchase. By implementing a dynamic pricing strategy, you should increase your Buy Box percentages over time.

How to Confirm You’ve Won the Featured Offer

According to Seller Central, the best way to determine if you have won the Buy Box or Feature Offer is by visiting the Product Detail Page for each of your ASINs. If your offer is being featured, you will notice within the Buy Box that this product is “Sold by” and your brand or Amazon seller name will appear. For example, below you see “WishingUWell” next to the sold by section, which means we have the Featured Offer for this particular product.

If your brand or seller name shows up in the “Other Sellers” section of the detail page, you are not the Featured Offer.

PRO TIP: It is possible to have multiple variations for the same product, you may be the Featured Offer for some of them and not for others. Each variation is a separate ASIN.


There’s no denying the power of Amazon—or the Buy Box, as it accounts for over 80% of sales on Amazon. This means if you want to be successful as a seller on this platform, you need to compete. Try your luck with getting featured in the search results or taking advantage of Sponsored Ads, but earning the coveted position at the top right corner of every product page will guarantee more sales and revenue.

Increase your profitability today by competing for the Buy Box with our in-house team of experts!

Contact WishingUWell today—our experts are here to help you with all-things Amazon!

Lastest Post

📦 Big Moves Ahead! 🚚

This move is a testament to our rapid growth and our readiness to leap into our next chapter. Our new space isn’t just bigger; it’s thoughtfully crafted to enhance teamwork, spark innovation, and promote well-being among our employees, ultimately elevating our efficiency and output.

Read More »

💊 Amazon’s New Compliance System for Supplements ⚕️

Amazon’s recent introduction of a new compliance system for supplements marks a significant shift in the way brands must manage product testing and documentation. This change comes on the heels of past issues that saw listings deactivated due to non-compliance, and it aims to streamline operations while ensuring higher standards for product integrity.

Read More »

Amazon Brand Store Content

Amazon A+ Content